How and When to Get a Second Opinion Before Surgery

It is often said that no one should have spine surgery unless they receive a second opinion from another surgeon. On the surface, this would sound like good old common sense, as two opinions are better than one. However, there is a trap in this line of thinking. When a patient sees a physician for a second opinion, this next opinion has a tendency to always sound smarter than the first opinion. This is a well-recognized phenomenon, but in reality the second opinion may not be the best one.

When should you get another opinion?

• Certainly if you are not comfortable with the first physician, then seeing another surgeon for an opinion is a good idea.
• If a surgeon cannot answer questions about the rationale for a proposed procedure or is vague on the surgical plan, another opinion is a good idea.
• If you suspect that the initial referrals was made on the basis of economic interests rather than who is best suited for your surgery, go for another opinion. (Referring physicians favor local surgeons who will do the surgery in a local facility, especially if they are in a multispeciality clinic. This is not saying that these physicians are not capable but that there is a possibility that the first referral one receives may not be the best.)
• Another time it is good to get a second opinion is if the initial back surgery did not work and another surgery is being proposed. This is especially true if it involves fusing further segments of the spine. Often, if the initial fusion surgery does not work, further surgery will not be helpful. Only in very specific circumstances (i.e. pseudoathrosis) is further surgery likely to be beneficial.
• There are times when a surgeon will ask a patient to get a confirmatory opinion prior to proceeding with surgery. In these cases it is best to let the treating surgeon pick the second opinion as they are best able to determine whose opinion they would value.

Otherwise, picking a surgeon for a second opinion is often difficult. As previously stated, the goal is to get an opinion from a respected, experienced and ethical surgeon. While it is not perfect, word of mouth is probably still the best measure as to who could be helpful in the second opinion process. This is, however, still a relatively arbitrary process.

The best thing for a patient seeking another opinion is to keep an open mind. You need to be as judgmental about the second opinion as for the first, and need to grill the second physician even further than the first. Beware of surgeons toting unrealistic expectations or who are overly dependent on “cutting edge” technologies. Focus on their experience with your specific type of back surgery and what the surgeon's past outcomes with that surgery are. What are the alternatives to a proposed procedure, and what is the expected natural history of the patients condition if they do not have the procedure? What are the risks and possible complications of the procedure, and if it doesn’t work, what would be the subsequent plan? Read all 38 Questions to Ask Your Surgeon Before Having Surgery.

Remember, the worst thing to do is assume the second opinion is automatically going to be better than the first. Keeping an open mind will prevent you from falling into this trap. And if you’re still not sure, ...get a third opinion.

Posted by: Peter Ullrich, MD