More Search Tools: Doctors Videos
Alternative Treatments
Welcome to Spine-health’s Alternative Treatment patient community. You can also read doctor approved Chiropractic, Massage Therapy, and Nutrition, Diet, and Weight Loss Articles.
13 replies [Last post]
User offline. Last seen 6 weeks 6 days ago. Offline
Joined: 08/03/2009
Posts: 141
Points: 290
accupunture

I have been going for accupuncture for about a month now, and can't belive I am in less pain. My spasms in my rt shoulder are considerably less, you can touch my shoulder without me screaming! My rib cage is also less painful. He is only working on my rt shoulder and rib cage right now, and said that after 2 months it should be at least 50% better. I have to admit, it's been a month and I am in less pain then I can remember being in for years. I have had a lump of muscle spasms that is visible in the back of my neck for many years. Now after a month of accupuncture it is still there, but it's decreased in size so much I can't believe it. I am not sure if it is visible to other people now, or if it can only be felt. I wouldn't wear my hair up in the summer because this lump of muscle looked as though I had a tumor on my neck it was so big. One doctor who I saw made me go for a CT scan for it because he thought I was wrong and it wasn't a muscle spasm.

Anyway, just thought I would let you know that this is helping me...

ilene

User offline. Last seen 1 year 38 weeks ago. Offline
Banned after receiveing more than 4 formal warnings
Joined: 12/30/2008
Posts: 3099
Points: 6230
Acupuncture --

I'm glad it's helping. I've been using acupuncture for at least 8 years, off and on, for a variety of issues. The guy I go to currently uses the needles to break up adhesions and also to "warm up" the tissues before doing body work to realign areas of soft tissue around my spine and pelvic girdle. He only practices in orthopedic cases.

His wife went to medical school for two years and really didn't like it, so switched to Chinese medicine. She uses acupuncture to treat primarily internal issues...so, together, they make a great team.

For many people, the results of an acupuncture treatment are too slow in coming. They want more instant results, so they do not feel it is effective. But slowly but surely people seem to get good results.

Thanks for posting and let us know how the progress continues.

Gwennie

_____________

I have no medical training. Comments are based on personal experience and lots of research and reading.
PLIF @ L4-5 with Peek cage, rods and screws Jan 2008
Lami-foraminotomy L5-S1 Jan 2009
Fusion L3-S1 coming up -- 1 June

garys37's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 year 26 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 08/05/2010
Posts: 8
Points: 16
How expensive is it?

I am convinced that acupuncture is as effective as medications or other traditional pain treatments, but my problem is that Medicare won't cover it.

Can you give me a ballpark figure on what it costs?

Locally, we have an acupuncturist who is highly regarded by some of the doctors I know. She has an MD as well as a degree in Chinese medicine.

_____________

L3/L4 disk extrusion and resultant radiculopathy
Quadrilateral PN from vincristine tx
Mirror-image pain
Possible fibromylagia

User offline. Last seen 44 weeks 3 days ago. Offline
Joined: 04/21/2010
Posts: 257
Points: 518
I live in CT and I'm paying $70 per session, once per week

I live in CT and I'm paying $70 per session, once per week. I have had five sessions so far. I can't tell any difference yet that I can directly attribute to Acupuncture, but they told me it could take 4-6 sessions to notice a benefit. I figure that I'll give them at least 7 or 8 sessions. If it works, it is worth every penny!

Best wishes!
Dave

_____________

9/2008 - L5/S1 Discectomy - Removed a section of disk the size of a man's thumb. Worked beautifully!
5/2009 - L5/S1 Repeat Discectomy - Had reherniated it riding my bike. Pain never resolved
1/2010 - TLIF at L5/S1 - fusion is stable, but pain is still unresolved ever since second discectomy
9/22/10 - Finally found a Physiatrist who has taken over my complete care. Looking forward to this next chapter of improved pain management.

User offline. Last seen 7 hours 29 min ago. Offline
Joined: 10/03/2009
Posts: 1751
Points: 3538
Glad to hear...

Glad to hear you are getting results.
I am starting to research alternative treatments as preventative. Accupuncture is one that intrigues me. Chiropractors scare me though I did agree to speak to one before my 1st surgery...he was good...he looked at my MRI report and said he would only treat me if he could work with my doctor. A sign of a good chiropractor.

I know accupuncture helped my sister. She swears her 2nd child who was breach turned b/c of the accupuncture (combo of needles, and oils rubbed into the feet).

User offline. Last seen 1 year 38 weeks ago. Offline
Banned after receiveing more than 4 formal warnings
Joined: 12/30/2008
Posts: 3099
Points: 6230
random thoughts ~~

As I guess with anything in life, so much depends on the person doing the acupuncture. I have heard a couple acupuncturists agree that the doctors who offer it as a sidelight of their practice are usually not as good as the ones that have gone to an accredited acupuncture school, have gone through the whole curriculum, and perform acupuncture on a regular basis.

Apparently MDs can do a much abbreviated course and can get a license without doing a clinical internship under a licensed acupuncturist. Consequently, they learn part of the technique but not all the different things one can do with acupuncture. I guess you could say they learn the "basics" but not all the subtleties.

Also some acupuncturists run more of a factory. The woman I went to for years did her training under one of these people. He would make the initial evaluation and then the patient would sign up for a certain number of treatments. The treatment was never changed from week to week...the same number of needles were used in the same locations, regardless of results. I prefer to go to someone who is only operating out of one or two rooms, who spends half the appointment talking to you, evaluating how the treatment worked, what should be changed, etc. In other words, a personalized approach.

Unfortunately many people have their first experience with acupuncture in a more clinical setting where things are more routine rather than personalized. They don't get any response the first couple times, and then conclude "acupuncture doesn't work."

This is unfortunate because a good acupuncturist can make a big difference for a whole variety of issues.

_____________

I have no medical training. Comments are based on personal experience and lots of research and reading.
PLIF @ L4-5 with Peek cage, rods and screws Jan 2008
Lami-foraminotomy L5-S1 Jan 2009
Fusion L3-S1 coming up -- 1 June

User offline. Last seen 2 days 10 hours ago. Offline
Joined: 08/05/2008
Posts: 46
Points: 94
does it work?

So, who's tried acupuncture for their back pain and does it work?
I am in the UK and my doctor has referred me on the NHS.

_____________

Angel

charry's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 week 1 day ago. Offline
Joined: 09/05/2008
Posts: 5601
Points: 11602
Hi Angel

I've tried acupuncture by my PT and it really relaxed me so much so I wanted to sleep right there so I guess it relaxes the muscles? I only had 7 treatments as I ran out of funds but hope you find some relief. Take care. Charry

_____________

Any answers I have is not medical advice only a Doctor can help you with that. Just sharing my personal experience as a fellow Spine Health member only. Mild DDD of complete lumbar area with recent healing of L5-S1 HD and annular tear.Leg &foot weakness nerve compression L4-L5.Mod. disc changes C5-C7 nerve impingement sore elbow and numb hand. Sept. 2011 MRI L4-L5 disc bulge and L5 facet joint and narrowing. Meds-Oxycontin 80mg,Cymbalta,Lyrica, Flexeril,Naproxen,Serax. Platinum Infrared heating pad. ER and Oncology trained and Cardiology RN on Disability. Keep the faith.

haglandc's picture
User offline. Last seen 2 hours 4 min ago. Offline
Moderator
Joined: 06/19/2008
Posts: 5798
Points: 12810
Angel

I have used acupuncture to battle pain and I think it is awesome. Only problem is the relief is short lived and the treatments have to be repeated a few times a week initially and the effects last longer the more treatments I receive.

"C"

_____________

“If it is not right do not do it; if it is not true do not say it.”

Marcus Aurelius

User offline. Last seen 4 weeks 4 days ago. Offline
Joined: 06/20/2008
Posts: 533
Points: 1098
cost

Garys37: It varies where you live, I'm in the Southwest and I paid $60 & $65 per session at two separate places; for me personally it didn't do much. Both places said try 3 treatments, if you don't improve don't come back. I do believe in it for many things; but it won't be a cure for everything, especially if there is something mechanically wrong. The infertility docs are into it alot too.

BarbF01's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 year 15 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 06/17/2010
Posts: 128
Points: 256
Here in NH.....

I pay $65/visit, as it's not covered by my ins. company. I too have found relief and better mobility (at least for 3 days, sometime more) after I have a session. My next one is about 1 week away, and I can't wait to get some sort of relief from this pain.

_____________

C-5 and C-6 fusion and discs replaced after car accident. Still suffering major pain and recently was diagnosed with a L-5 and S-1 herniation. Recently diagnosed w/ Fibro too and just started on Lyrica.

User offline. Last seen 1 year 10 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 08/27/2008
Posts: 225
Points: 472
Does the acupuncture simply

Does the acupuncture simply relieve pain or does it actually help to fix what is wrong, such as herniated disc?

haglandc's picture
User offline. Last seen 2 hours 4 min ago. Offline
Moderator
Joined: 06/19/2008
Posts: 5798
Points: 12810
Not certain

Not certain that there's a definitive answer for you on this. If you believe in the medicine behind the acupuncture, then I would say "yes". Acupuncture helps set the body's own healing and pain relieving abilities back into synch. So in essence it "could" possibly encourage your body to heal itself independent of surgical intervention. I am only speaking from my limited knowledge on acupuncture. I have had great success with acupuncture and do believe in its ability to help.

"C"

_____________

“If it is not right do not do it; if it is not true do not say it.”

Marcus Aurelius

User offline. Last seen 1 year 10 weeks ago. Offline
Joined: 08/27/2008
Posts: 225
Points: 472
Thanks! I am trying to keep

Thanks! I am trying to keep positive about it helping! at this time I am dealing with swelling, pain and black and blue directly on my cervical spine..not sure if it is from the acupuncture or my last epidural..

Jump to: