Welcome, Friend!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Protect anonymity
We strongly suggest that members do not include their email addresses. Once that is published , your email address is available to anyone on the internet , including hackers.

All discussions and comments that contain an external URL will be automatically moved to the spam queue. No external URL pointing to a medical web site is permitted. Forum rules also indicate that you need prior moderator approval. If you are going to post an external URL, contact one of the moderators to get their approval.
There are no medical professionals on this forum side of the site. Therefore, no one is capable or permitted to provide any type of medical advice.
This includes any analysis, interpretation, or advice based on any diagnostic test

The main site has all the formal medical articles and videos for you to research on.

2ND Opinion, Now what?

grandmesamomggrandmesamom Posts: 181
edited 06/11/2012 - 7:23 AM in Neck Pain: Cervical
Greetings to all. I went and got a second opionion from a leading Ortho spine specialist. Boy was his interpitation different. My NS if you recall thought my problem was a medical mystery and disputed every radiologic and EMG finding. He wanted to do a foraminotomy but wouldn't guarantee that it would help with my weakness. I see this new Dr and his interpitation was very frightening.He was very alarmed by the weakness and said my tricep,deltoid and bicep muscle were all involved. He stated it wasn't a mystery to him and that I needed surgery ASAP to prevent any further nerve damage. He wants to do a 2 level ACDF, flip me over and do a foraminotomy. I had a horrible time digesting all of this information because I had hoped for better news. He went on to explain that the C5 6 had a large central herniation which was causing compression. There were also large osteophytes pressing on different areas. What a huge difference in opinions!!! Do I have time for a 3rd opinion? My instincts about the NS was correct. I almost feel like he is hiding something. Why he would continue to deny there was a problem is a mystery to me! However the Ortho Spine scared the heck out of me !!!
Who do you beleive? Any suggestions? He told me straight out that surgery was emergent to save the arm muscles. When will this all end??? Any input is appreciated because my faith is failing in these Drs ideas. Bethy


  • I would definately seek a 3rd opinion, preferrably from another NS. This would scare the heck out of me too. I am currently also seeking our a 2nd opinion from a NS. My OS said I need cervical decompression. Woudl you mind posting your MRI results so I can see what they say? Thanks a lot and geez, good luck to you and keep us posted.

  • While one is sitting there touting medical mystery and scratching his head, you've got a specialist who seems to have knowledgeable information. I'd say if you can, get a 3rd opinion. I know he's saying he wants to do it NOW but if it's as major of a situation as he says it is, personally if this were me, I'd want confirmation from another party that yes, this is exactly what needs to be done. Good luck to you and keep us updated! :)))
  • advertisement
  • This is so familiar to me.....I went to a neruosurgeon first who sent me for PT and said everything would be fine....my right arm pain increased and 8 months later I went to my pcp with the pain who sent me to an ortho spine surgeon who took one look at my MRI and said I needed surgery asap....I think it was the right choice even though I still have pain and many other things wrong which I contribute to waiting too long for surgery.

  • Just to make sure that this doctor isn't trying to get you in to surgery, for the sake of doing it.

    Your second opinion seems a lot more informative, which I would probably be more willing to trust. However, when I started my journey, I was told a lot of times that surgery is what these doctors do. Think about that when getting the advice to have the surgery done.

    On the one hand, they are trained in this field. On the other, this is their business... their way of making a living. Just make sure that this doctor isn't overstating the facts.

    Good Luck
  • Wow what a difference in Doctors. I would get a third and see what they say. Wow I cant believe how bad the second doctor is saying you are. Good Luck
  • advertisement
  • I am in the process of getting an appt for a third opinion. My husband is freaked because he thinks its such an emergency that I don't have time for another opinion. The opinions were so far from each other that I will not feel comfortable until I see another MD.The OS was warning me that the longer I wait,the more chance of permanent injury I may have.Thanks for your input.
  • Amanda, I agree with you. I guess surgeons make their money by doing surgery. This guy is a specialist in spines and I am sure that surgery keeps him busy. While I do not want surgery, I would certainly love to keep my left arm as a functioning part of my body. I will not go into surgery until I have another opinion.The surgery sounded way to involved and serious . The question also is how conservative and how aggressive do you allow the Drs to get?
  • to hear you're looking to get another opinion. I think it'll be worth it and give you the peace of mind that if you do end up with surgery it will have been warranted. :)))
  • So many of us with similar stories!
    I had one NS who told me my problem was I was too tall, thin, long neck and big boobs and TOS.
    I got a 2nd and am scheduled for surgery on 10/15. He was completely horrified by the 1st's comments and Thoracic Outlet diagnosis. He said, it didn't take a brain surgeon to be a brain surgeon with my MRI and EMG. :))(
    I felt so much comfort with the 2nd NS. He was such a pro and had such a caring attitude.
    I guess that's why they call it practicing medicine!
  • My first was with an Ortho who I think if he had a scalpel would have done surgery that day in his office! No thanks! My second was a neuro who gave me 50/50 chance of relief but the then 85% after my discogram. I then got another NS opinion who would do anterior approach, the first posterior. I then got my 4th opinion another Ortho spine. Gave me 97% chance I would be better, recommended the ALIF.

    I could tell this was the right doctor for me. I knew from a friend that he had a great reputation as she worked in the hospital that he worked in. I had exhusted all options at the point I saw him. I scheduled with doctor number 4 and have not regretted my decision. My point is you need to feel comfortable and safe with whoever is doing your surgery. Keep looking for that person, they are out there somewhere! Good luck!
Sign In or Register to comment.