Welcome, Friend!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!


Quick Start Forum Video Tutorial

There are no medical professionals on this forum side of the site. Therefore, no one is capable or permitted to provide any type of medical advice.
This includes any analysis, interpretation, or advice based on any diagnostic test

The main site has all the formal medical articles and videos for you to research on.

We're building a better forum experience with you in mind. Beginning June 26, 2019, all Veritas Health forums will move to forum.veritashealth.com.

Learn More

calcium and magnesium

noraparkernnoraparker Posts: 2
edited 09/16/2013 - 6:44 AM in Osteoporosis and Fractures
i have severe osteoporosis, which has caused me to have 4 spinal fractures. The treatment i have been recieving from my doctor is high calcium and vit d caplets, and risondrate {weekly}, i also have to take a high dose of co codomol 4 times daily. However i seem to have developed really bad palpitations, and when i mentioned them to my doctor that i had read that too much calcium can cause heart problems, he poo-hood what i had to say and told me to keep on taking my meds and stop reading literature! I have become a member of the magnesium advocacy group and they seem to have proof that calcium supplements do not do the slightest bit of good, and that the reason the bones become brittle is because of a magnesium deficiency, and that calcium actually causes heart problems! Apparantly it is magnesium that helps the body convert calcium into a useful vitamin.., and that no matter how much calcium you take it wont work if you have a magnesium deficiency,
i am not explaining it very well, you would have to read the information provided on the web site to understand better, but as a result of this i am considering taking myself off all the calcium supplements and following the advice of **Edited to remove physician name**, the magnesium expert, but i am so afraid of worsening my condition! Has anyone else had any experience of alternative treatments, ie: magnesium?

You agree not to post specific physician names or health care facilities names on Spine-Health.com.


  • If you are taking calcium you MUST take Vitamin-D.this is a hormone,however,also a precursor to the calcium being able to do what it's meant.just taking calcium is useless without the combo.magnesium is for bone health and it will of course help,but without proper understanding of the function of vitamin precursors that set the stage,ugh!
    I have osteoporosis,I can't rotate my bed mattress without fx ribs,starting lawnmower,fx ribs reaching incorrectly,fx ribs.I was dx 3x years ago with Graves disease,hyperthyroidism- /with hyperparathyroidism-my bones actually hurt,thus since dx I've literally begun to reinforce my diet with more vitamins than ever,I choose according to the issue,bone -vit.d,calcium,magnesium-manganese works for cramps in the calves.it's really a matter of being willing to be self educated by investing in researching all amino acids,vitamins,and the combination.
    Wish you well, linnietea
  • Hi Nora,
    Well excess doses of anything be it calcium, magnesium or potassium can cause palpitations. I would recommend you to get a second opinion instead of blindly following your doctor's prescribed medicines before the condition worsens further.
  • advertisement
This discussion has been closed.
Sign In or Register to comment.