Two professional opinions are better than one, especially when you are considering spine surgery, right? Sounds right, but there may be a trap in this line of thinking.

Is surgery really the best treatment for your herniated disc? Read: Surgery Options for a Herniated Disc

See Surgery Options for a Herniated Disc

When a patient sees a physician for a second opinion, the second opinion has a tendency to sound smarter than the first opinion. This is a well-recognized phenomenon, but in reality the second opinion may not be the best one.

Watch Back Pain Videos and Back Surgery Videos

When to consider a second opinion

So, the question is when should you get another opinion?

  • Certainly if you are not comfortable with the first physician for any reason, then seeing another surgeon for an opinion is a good idea.
  • If a surgeon cannot answer questions about the rationale for a proposed procedure or is vague on the surgical plan, another opinion is a good idea.
  • If your personal goals are different from the surgeon’s, e.g. if you really want to avoid surgery to treat your pain, and the surgeon is saying that surgery is really your only option.
  • If you suspect that the initial referral was made on the basis of economic interests rather than who is best suited for your surgery, go for another opinion. (Referring physicians tend to favor local surgeons who will do the surgery in a local facility, especially if they are in a multi-specialty clinic. This is not saying that these physicians are not capable, but that there is a possibility that the first referral one receives may not be the best.)
  • It is also good to get a second opinion if the initial back surgery did not work and another surgery is being proposed. This advice is especially true if it involves fusing further segments of the spine. Often, if the initial fusion surgery does not work, further surgery will not be helpful. Only in very specific circumstances (i.e. pseudoarthrosis) is further surgery likely to be beneficial.
  • There are times when a surgeon will ask a patient to get a confirmatory opinion prior to proceeding with surgery. In these cases, it is often best to let the treating surgeon pick the source for the second opinion, as they are best able to determine whose opinion they would value.

Picking a surgeon for a second opinion is often difficult. As previously stated, the goal is to get an opinion from a skilled, experienced, and ethical surgeon. While it is not perfect, word of mouth is probably still the best measure as to who could be helpful in the second opinion process. However, this is still a relatively arbitrary process.

See How to Select a Spine Surgeon


Online second opinion services

In addition to physically going to a surgeon for a second opinion, there are now some online second opinion services available, including services from surgeons who will look at your medical information online and provide a second opinion, as well as radiology services, with radiologists who view your x-rays, MRI scans, etc., and provide a second opinion.

The online services have the potential benefit of providing an unbiased opinion (i.e. the online service is not going to benefit financially if you have surgery), and the obvious drawback is that they do not evaluate you and your condition in person.

The surgeon interview

The best advice for a patient seeking another surgical opinion is to keep an open mind. You need to be as judgmental about the second opinion as for the first, and need to grill the second physician even further than the first.

At a minimum, you should cover these topics with the surgeon:

  • Focus on the surgeon’s experience with your specific type of back surgery.
  • Find out what the surgeon's past outcomes with that type of surgery have been.
  • Ask what are the alternatives to a proposed procedure.
Epidural steroid injections are considered conservative treatment, and they may help you avoid surgery for some time: Cervical Epidural Steroid Injection Video
  • Ask what the condition progression would be if you don't have the surgery.
  • Get details about all the risks and possible complications of the procedure.
  • Ask what the plan would be if the surgery doesn't work.

For a more complete surgeon interview guide, see 40 Questions to Ask Your Surgeon Before Having Surgery.

As a general rule, be very wary of second opinions from surgeons who:

  • Make claims that sound too good to be true. There are no magical cures (i.e. painless surgery)
  • Are toting unrealistic expectations
  • Are overly dependent on "cutting edge" technologies

See Guidelines for Evaluating a Spine Surgeon

As a final note of advice, the worst approach is to assume the second opinion is automatically going to be better than the first. Keeping an open mind will prevent you from falling into this trap. And if you’re still not sure, get a third opinion.

Learn more:

Specific Questions to Ask Your Spine Surgeon

Preparing to See A Doctor for Back and Neck Pain


Find a Physician Near You

Search for a Doctor