Welcome, Friend!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!


Quick Start Forum Video Tutorial

Protect anonymity
We strongly suggest that members do not include their email addresses. Once that is published , your email address is available to anyone on the internet , including hackers.

All discussions and comments that contain an external URL will be automatically moved to the spam queue. No external URL pointing to a medical web site is permitted. Forum rules also indicate that you need prior moderator approval. If you are going to post an external URL, contact one of the moderators to get their approval.
There are no medical professionals on this forum side of the site. Therefore, no one is capable or permitted to provide any type of medical advice.
This includes any analysis, interpretation, or advice based on any diagnostic test

The main site has all the formal medical articles and videos for you to research on.

cracking noise



  • I have popping in my neck and it is clear on the imaging that a disc is herniated. It does sound like bone on bone. What type of test have they run, like MRI, Myelograms, discogram, x-rays? As far as the paralysis in the lower limb, have they done a emg study or any sensory testing? By any chance did they mention you have degenative disc disease? Keep in mind at your age everyone's spine is going to show issues, just the nature of how it works. Try looking at a dermatone map and see if any of your leg issues match the where you are hearing the noise.

    This is a forum for patients. Not to many doctors actually will blog on here. I agree with Ron being you need to be your own advocate and find some answers. There isn't much in your post that a doctor could answer if they were responding to post. Someone just saying they have noise in the spine, wouldn't lead them to any conclusions at all. I would keep looking for a doctor whom can help you. Possible see a neurologist they may have some insights as to your issues and can refer you out from there. It is possible the paralysis in the leg is unrelated to the issues you are having in your spine. Take care.
  • I appologize for the negativity But 11 years ago i started feeling an unusual pain in my back along with grinding where the pain existed. My doctor did xrays and found nothing,so i was told to goto a chiropractor. after a year starting once a month and ending in three days a week, the ciropractor told me my back, could not be corrected in those means.Surgery would be the only alturnative for me but my doctor dissagreed. That was 11 years ago. After five opinions I gave up, and delbt with the disconfort and pain.untill two years ago i started having extreme pain in my legs and arms and after poping my back the pain subsided.After two - three hrs of movement back to the same situation. i started seeing another ortheropedic that found a couple minor degenerative discs and an blocked nerve in my l5 area that was causing my groinal pain but not telling me.another ortheropedic told me on a second op.and still they still tell me that my back is not that bad from the catscan. Now i have pains going to my stomache, kidneys, and chest. After self treatment they subside. but the grinding areas still cause me great pain. i have had nerve tests, physical theropy for three months making it worse and the PTP said it wasn't working just posibly doing more damage in those areas. And medications I told my doctor no narcotics if possible unless absolutly nessesary.Well trial and ERROR,has been the case, meds were neurotin, cimbulta, lyrica, two epidurals the second damaged another nerve that constantly hurts as well now.And an antiflamitory by injection, i can't take ibuprofin, or asprin. After doing some studying my scan and finding a few other things thatmight be causes, fracture lines in four vertibres, and no one is looking at those. the worst part is i get the same answers, it doesn't look bad and nothing else can be done at this time. i have tried to work and was let go due to incompletion of duties due to the pain. walking and standing hurts, sitting for long periods hurt. Now ive been known to work with broken bones,pulled mucscles, even with a 6"torn abdomonBut this is too much. I have a family i need to support and have no income and have been out of work for a 1.5 years living on state assistance. I have no support by any doctors in fixing this or temporary disability to help out. 11 years ago i heard nothing can be done at this time, Now three thousand forums with the same issues and the same medical responses. 11 years of complaints of gringing poping no from gas but bone pulling bone. if it was gass there would a coushin and not grinding.
    As for what hasn't been done in 11 years in the medical field i've done on a personal level, and have possibilities but only docs know best????
    I need some one to say i have an answer.
  • advertisement
  • Read the reply to ron as far as a neurologist goes thats next. but as for alll of the tests you mentioned, well all ahve been done, i was just clearly stating that my back pain has been going on for 11 years, and most of the pain is where the grinding happens. After 9 years of grinding now these other symptoms are occuring, and to see others going through the same thing and people are being told its gas in the joints well some i can say yes but not all, and more should be looked into other theories. For many years a few people complained that their body hurt all of time, diagnosis:vibral mialga, a lump in the breast 40 years ago was just a cyst. The medical field is working on better diagnostics but if they don't have a clear picture then, solving the problems. I was dianosed with DDD, but three doctors say it's not bad enough to cause the symptoms, so what is it then? And how many people out there are suffering from this that are misdiagnosed, or undiagnosed. Im just giving my voice and if there is any one out there that has had a doctor that had an answer maybe they could give me some thing or some one to turn to with a solution. And hope that i don't go crippled waiting for the solution and others as well.
  • MetalneckMetalneck The Island of Misfit toysPosts: 1,778
    aldo berardi said:
    I have theories for the doctors researching this for 11 years and non have listened. If there is a doctor that will reply to this with a private message i'll give you what i have.LOL

    In this and another thread - you imply that you have the answers to these and other conditions.

    Would you please share with us what your research has revealed? I am sure that even though we are not doctors - we would benefit from your findings assuming they are sound and substaintiated.

    Why the request for PM's - share your secrets with the spiney world! (Please)

  • That's the truth. For everyone here with a clear diagnosis there are 10 who struggle to find the true source of their problem. The body is an incredibly complex thing. We also have doctors who are educated in one specific area and often will not look outside that box.

    I had an MRI that showed my herniation yet an orthosurgeon said it didn't match my pain so it wasn;t the problem. The neurologist said the same and treated me for months. It wasn't until I went back to the first doctor and demanded they look again that they showed me the report. Even then I had another surgeon who said it couldn't be and even if it was it wasn't bad enough to operate.

    Well 2 months later the original pain is gone. Pain that couldn't be caused by that herniation.

    The moral of the story is don't give up. Find a new doctor and have them take a fresh look. Keep researching and keep asking questions. Keeping accurate notes is also critical. You need to know which doc said what and when you move one way what happens. Memory is faulty at best and when you are in pain it is completely unreliable.
  • advertisement
  • My 3rd PM Dr. said "interesting that the MRI shows no disc herniation and annular tear that you had last year but experience the same symptoms as if you still had the herniation at L5-S1". I had facet injections and S1 and an epidural. Now the cracking shifting noise is gone mainly and I thought it was an unstable spine! Keep looking for someone to help with the pain. Best wishes. Charry
    DDD of lumbar spine with sciatica to left hip,leg and foot. L4-L5 posterior disc bulge with prominent facets, L5-S1 prominent facets with a posterior osteocartilaginous bar. Mild bilateral foraminal narrowing c-spine c4-c7 RN
This discussion has been closed.
Sign In or Register to comment.